How Much Does Car Insurance Go Up After an Accident

August 9, 2024 | By Francis Injury: Car & Truck Accident Lawyers
How Much Does Car Insurance Go Up After an Accident

The accident is over, but your financial headache might just be beginning.

But before you panic about skyrocketing premiums, let's uncover the truth behind those post-accident insurance hikes.

In this guide, we'll reveal:

  • The factors that influence these increases
  • The average rate hikes
  • How long these penalties last

Don't let one mistake derail your financial future. The team at Francis Firm has seen it all and knows how to fight back against unfair rate hikes. Call (817) 329-9001 now for your free consultation with a car accident attorney.

Your accident shouldn't define your financial future. Let's explore your options together.

Factors Influencing Insurance Rate Increases

Insurance premiums often rise significantly after an accident, and several factors contribute to how much your rates will go up.

Severity of the Accident

The severity of an accident is one of the most significant determinants of rate increases. Minor accidents causing little damage might result in smaller increases, whereas major accidents with extensive damage or injuries can lead to substantial hikes in your premiums​​.

Driver's Record

Your driving history plays a critical role. If you have a clean record before the accident, the increase may be less severe compared to a driver with previous violations or accidents. Texas insurers consider multiple incidents as indicators of higher risk.

State Regulations

Texas has specific regulations that impact insurance rate increases after an accident. The Texas Department of Insurance regulates how insurers can adjust rates, and while there are no strict caps, insurers must justify their rate increases. Additionally, Texas follows an "at-fault" insurance system. This means that the driver responsible for causing the accident (the at-fault driver) is liable for damages. This system contrasts with no-fault states, where each driver's insurance typically covers their own damages regardless of who caused the accident. As a result, at-fault drivers in Texas can face significant rate increases as insurers account for the higher risk associated with their driving​.

Insurance Company Policies

An insurance officer is writing on a clipboard while an insurance agent examines a black car, reviewing car accident insurance policies.

Insurance companies in Texas have varying policies regarding rate increases after an accident. Some offer accident forgiveness programs, preventing rate hikes for the first at-fault accident, while others might impose significant increases immediately​​.

Age and Gender

In Texas, younger drivers, particularly teenagers, often face higher increases after an accident due to their higher risk profiles. Male drivers under 25 and female drivers under 21 typically see the most significant hikes. Seniors over 70 might experience higher rates due to an increased risk of accidents and higher medical costs associated with injuries.​

Vehicle Type and Usage

The type of vehicle and its usage significantly impact rate increases. High-performance or expensive vehicles usually result in higher premiums after an accident due to the increased repair costs. Vehicles for long commutes or commercial purposes might also experience higher rate hikes. In Texas, where trucks and SUVs are prevalent, these vehicles might see different rate adjustments based on their repair costs and risk profiles​.

Average Rate Increases

Understanding the average rate increases following an accident can help Texas drivers anticipate their insurance costs. Rate hikes vary based on the details of the accident, the driver's history, and the insurance company's policies.

National Average Increase

On average, car insurance premiums increase by about 20% to 50% after an accident. This translates to an additional $300 to $800 per year, depending on the severity of the accident and the insurance company involved​​.

Examples by State

Insurance rate increases can differ significantly by state. In Texas, drivers can expect a substantial rise in their premiums after an accident. According to recent data, Texas drivers experience an average increase of around 71% after an at-fault accident​​. This higher-than-average increase reflects the state's regulations and risk assessments by insurance companies.

Below is a comparison of average rate increases in a few of the states with higher-than-average rate increases:

StateAverage Annual Rate Before AccidentAverage Annual Rate After AccidentPercentage Increase
Texas$1,827$3,12371%
California$2,207$3,70368%
New Jersey$1,840$3,52692%
Florida$2,364$4,23279%
New York$2,062$3,68378%

Duration of Rate Increases

The duration of insurance rate increases after an accident can vary based on several factors, including state regulations and insurance company policies.

Typical Penalty Periods

In Texas, as in many other states, insurance companies typically raise rates for three to five years following an at-fault accident​​. This period can vary depending on the severity of the accident and the driver's subsequent record. For instance, minor accidents may result in a shorter penalty period, while severe accidents causing significant damage or injuries can lead to a longer duration of increased premiums.

Impact of Multiple Accidents

If a driver in Texas is involved in multiple accidents within a short period, the rate increases can be more severe and prolonged. For example, two at-fault accidents within a year can double or even triple the insurance premiums​​. Insurance companies view such drivers as high risk, leading to substantial and extended rate hikes.

Additional Factors Influencing Duration

Several additional factors can influence the duration of rate increases:

  • Type of Claim: Comprehensive claims (e.g., theft, vandalism; more on this below) typically result in smaller and shorter rate increases compared to at-fault collision claims​.
  • Insurance Provider: Different insurance companies have their own policies regarding the duration of rate increases. Some may offer accident forgiveness programs that prevent rate hikes for the first at-fault accident, effectively reducing the penalty period.

Ways to Mitigate Rate Increases

While insurance rate hikes after an accident are often unavoidable, there are several strategies Texas drivers can use to mitigate these increases.

Shopping for New Insurance

One of the most effective ways to handle a rate increase is to shop around for a new insurance policy. Insurance companies use different criteria to determine premiums, so another provider might offer a more competitive rate even after an accident. Comparing quotes from multiple insurers can help you find the best deal. Utilizing online comparison tools and working with an independent insurance agent can make this process easier​​.

Accident Forgiveness Programs

A young businesswoman is reviewing an accident forgiveness contract at her desk, carefully considering the terms, conditions, and benefits it offers.

Many insurance companies offer accident forgiveness programs that can prevent your rates from increasing after your first at-fault accident. These programs often require an additional premium but can save you money in the long run by avoiding a significant rate hike. It's essential to check if your current insurer offers this program or if it's worth switching to a provider that does.

Maintaining a Clean Record

Maintaining a clean driving record post-accident can help reduce the impact of a rate increase. Avoiding additional traffic violations and accidents over the next few years can demonstrate to insurers that you are a responsible driver, potentially leading to lower rates in the future. Completing a defensive driving course might also qualify you for discounts, further mitigating the rate increase​.

Adjusting Your Coverage

Another way to manage your insurance costs is by adjusting your coverage. Increasing your deductibles can lower your monthly premiums, although this means you'll pay more out-of-pocket if you file a claim. You can also review your policy to ensure you aren't paying for unnecessary coverage. For instance, if you have an older vehicle, you might consider dropping collision or comprehensive coverage​​.

Utilizing Discounts

Many insurance companies offer a variety of discounts that can help offset the cost of increased premiums. These might include multi-policy discounts, safe driver discounts, or discounts for features like anti-theft devices and safety equipment. Make sure to inquire about all available discounts and ensure you are receiving any that you qualify for​​.

Comprehensive Claims and Their Impact

While at-fault accidents typically result in the most significant rate increases, comprehensive claims also play a role, albeit to a lesser extent.

Definition and Examples of Comprehensive Claims

Comprehensive claims cover vehicle damages not caused by a collision. These include incidents like theft, vandalism, fire, natural disasters, and hitting an animal. For example, if a hailstorm in Texas damages your car, it would be covered under a comprehensive claim​​.

Comparison to At-Fault Accidents

Comprehensive claims generally result in smaller rate increases compared to at-fault accidents because they are not typically the driver's fault. For instance, while an at-fault accident might increase your premiums by 20% to 90%, a comprehensive claim might only lead to a minor increase, often less than 10%​​.

However, multiple comprehensive claims within a short period can still lead to higher premiums, as insurers might view frequent claims as an indicator of higher risk​​.

How a Lawyer Can Help

Insurance for court claims in the courtroom. Gavels and small toy car models, with two cars on the table in the court. Lawyer service concept trial. Close-up images.

Hiring a lawyer can provide significant advantages, especially in maximizing your compensation and ensuring fair treatment from insurance companies. Here’s how a lawyer can assist you:

1. Evaluating Your Case

A lawyer can assess the specifics of your accident, review the police reports, gather evidence, and determine the viability of your case. This initial evaluation helps in understanding the potential outcomes and the compensation you might be entitled to.

2. Handling Insurance Companies

Insurance companies often aim to minimize payouts. A lawyer can negotiate with insurers on your behalf, ensuring that you receive a fair settlement. They understand the tactics insurance adjusters use and can effectively counteract lowball offers​.

3. Calculating Damages

Accurately calculating the full extent of your damages is crucial. This includes not only immediate medical expenses and vehicle repairs but also future medical costs, lost wages, and non-economic damages like pain and suffering. A lawyer has the expertise to include all these factors in your claim, potentially increasing your compensation​.

4. Proving Liability

Establishing fault in an accident is essential for a successful claim. Lawyers gather and present evidence, such as eyewitness testimonies, traffic camera footage, and expert analyses, to build a strong case proving the other party’s liability​. They also use Texas’s comparative negligence laws to distribute fault among all involved parties, reducing your liability. By minimizing your liability, you can not only receive more compensation from your claim, but you will also minimize insurance premium increases.

The legal process comes with strict deadlines and procedural rules. A lawyer can handle all the paperwork, file necessary documents on time, and ensure compliance with Texas state laws. This reduces the risk of errors that could jeopardize your claim​​.

6. Litigation Support

If your case goes to court, having a lawyer is indispensable. They can represent you in court, present a compelling argument, cross-examine witnesses, and handle any legal challenges that arise during the trial. Their courtroom experience is crucial for achieving a favorable outcome​​.

7. Providing Peace of Mind

Dealing with the aftermath of an accident can be stressful. Hiring a lawyer allows you to focus on recovery while they handle the legal intricacies.

8. Contingency Fee Basis

Many personal injury lawyers work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you don’t pay any upfront costs. They only get paid if you win your case, making legal representation accessible without financial strain​.

9. Accident Forgiveness and Insurance Negotiations

Lawyers can help you understand your policy’s specifics, including accident forgiveness clauses. They can also negotiate with your insurer to ensure that these clauses are applied correctly, potentially preventing unjust rate hikes​​.

Don't Let One Accident Derail Your Future

You've been hit twice—first by the accident, now by soaring insurance rates. But here's the truth: You have more power than you think. Working with the right legal team of personal injury lawyers can make all the difference.

Here's how we turn the tables:

A small wooden toy car, a sound block, a gavel, and scales of justice rest on an office table, with people conversing in the background. Legal services, court, law, and insurance.
  • Slash Your Liability: We dig deep, uncovering evidence that could dramatically reduce your fault.
  • Master Negotiators: We speak 'insurance language' fluently, often securing rates they swore were impossible.
  • Texas Law Experts: We leverage state-specific laws to maximize your protection and minimize your costs.

The best part? You pay nothing unless we win. That's our ironclad guarantee.

Why choose the Francis Firm?

  • Proven Track Record: We've saved clients thousands in insurance hikes and secured millions in settlements.
  • Full-Service Support: From evidence collection to courtroom battles, we handle it all.
  • Peace of Mind: Focus on healing while we tackle the legal maze.

Time is critical. Every day without help could cost you.

Don't let insurance companies exploit your vulnerability. Let the Francis Firm level the playing field. Call us today at (817) 329-9001.